Barbecue restaurants

Krolicks Chicken BBQ

4.5 63 reviews Closed 2745 NY-16, Olean, NY 14760, United States

Discover this place

Krolicks BBQ at Trappers Park in Olean offers a classic barbecue dining experience rooted in traditional American smokehouse cuisine. Located along NY-16, this family-owned restaurant serves a menu focused on slow-smoked meats, including ribs, brisket, and chicken, accompanied by a variety of classic sides. The atmosphere blends casual comfort with a rustic charm, reflecting its setting within the Trappers Park locale. The restaurant emphasizes hearty, flame-smoked flavors typical of regional BBQ traditions, appealing to both locals and visitors seeking an authentic meat-centric meal. While part of the Krolicks BBQ brand, this location maintains its own distinct presence in Olean's dining landscape, contributing to the community’s selection of smokehouse venues. Staffed by a team familiar with barbecue preparation and service, the establishment offers a straightforward, approachable dining environment suitable for families and casual outings. Krolicks BBQ at Trappers Park stands as a notable destination for those interested in classic barbecue fare prepared with time-honored techniques in a relaxed setting.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Curbside pickup
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Dining options

Dinner

Amenities

Restroom

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Krolicks Chicken BBQ before visiting.

Reviews for Krolicks Chicken BBQ

4.5

63 reviews

100%

18%

32%

Review highlights

Based on 63 reviews

Krolicks BBQ at Trappers Park in Olean receives generally positive feedback for its flavorful barbecue, particularly its ribs and chicken, which many customers describe as juicy and well-prepared. The family-owned and operated nature of the business contributes to a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere, with attentive and friendly staff frequently noted. While the location benefits from good service and a convenient setting, some patrons have expressed mixed feelings about consistency, especially regarding the chicken dishes, which have received varied responses. Additionally, the quality of sides is consistently praised. Overall, Krolicks BBQ is recognized for delivering strong barbecue offerings and a hospitable environment, though maintaining consistency across different locations remains an area for improvement in some customer experiences.

Vernon Robinson Jr

Oct 11, 2025

First time at this location and I was a bit disappointed. The service and location is great as I had been hoping someone would take over the Trappers location with something better. While I love the Krolicks north of here, this one has started out bad for me. It's like Trappers dried Chicken BBQ all over again. Sides were great and our ribs were tasty. One more Chicken dinner like that and I'll just travel north like usual.

Thomas Huttenmaier

Oct 07, 2025

It's unfortunate that it seems like your competition is leaving fake reviews my brisket I had on sat was some of the best brisket I've ever had in my life and I've gone to a lot of different restaurants and the food the service everything was top-notch thank you for having such a good place out in the country

John Brancato

Jul 20, 2025

Chicken is absolutely amazing amd juicy as can be. Both locations. Family owned amd operated. Staff is always pleasant